Track opinions wanted

[Loz]

playing around with something, and not sure which I prefer.

Both of these are the same, but with a different synth, which one does everyone think sounds better?

(also, ignore the snare, it's rubbish)

One (http://nodataavailable.com/Music/acidthing.mp3)

Two (http://nodataavailable.com/Music/acidthing-2.mp3)

I like the the more organic feel of the first one, but I also like the cleanness of the second. what do you guys reckon?

[tsr_robban]

those are not tracks, maybe loops... the difference between the two, what you turned a knob to the left?

[tsr_robban]

can i have your oppinion on this track? specially the vocal part... does it need more reverb?

http://www.otto-tsr.com/gb_-_i_love_you_baby.mp3

[Loz]

those are not tracks, maybe loops... the difference between the two, what you turned a knob to the left?

it's work in progress, I just wanted opinions on the synth

one is recorded from my G2, the other is my SH-101.

[Loz]

does it need more reverb?

yes

[tsr_robban]

just use one that you like and then get on with it or you'll never get anything done.

[Loz]

that's the point, I like them both, and listened to them enough to have no objectivity

[tsr_robban]

aha, use the sh101, its a cooler piece of gear ;)

[thembuzz]

i think i prefer the second. i like the bounce. i also like the snare. trashy. some people might think my opinion on snares doesn't count for shit, but they know nothing

[[sik]]

number two...no reason. sounds better to me.

[mdk]

number two.

now get on with it.

[JonnySpeed]

mummy, i need to do a number two...

please add some wonk and some scratched beats

[Loz]

please add some wonk and some scratched beats

that's the plan.

[thembuzz]

can i have your oppinion on this track? specially the vocal part... does it need more reverb?

http://www.otto-tsr.com/gb_-_i_love_you_baby.mp3

that rules

[Sheridan]

yeah, number two works better for a dance track for me. it has more bite.

[JonnySpeed]

that's the plan.

wakka wakka eeeeeeek arrrrrrrrrrrr

pirate beats
http://www.bearfamilygifts.com/bear/pirate-bear-blackie-w.jpg

[pille'ocheoni]

tsr rob i fucking love this track!

[stinkfinger]

is the second one the sh101? i like that better than the first, a bit fatter, but sounds a wee bit static if u know what i mean. needs a bit of tweakage

[Loz]

everyone prefers #2, which is actually the G2

I'm working it further now, I'll post something up when I've done a lot more to it

[emef]

cant you decide yourself what sounds good?
making music is about making yourself happy, doing just what YOU want
be decisive for fucks sake

'oooh everyone prefers t2 so i'm gonna go with that'


PUFF


my advice would be to make some electro house... its fucking massive at the moment

[Loz]

my advice would be to make some electro house... its fucking massive at the moment

the problem is, I tried to think which I preferred more, and I couldn't decide at all. I wanted some objective opinions from people I know have fairly similar taste to me.

Besides, now I've had the push, I think I do prefer #2, just because it sounds cleaner and harder.

[emef]

how could you not decide??????
producing music is about making decisions
if ya can't even decide what synth sounds better its a bit of a poor do

sorry to be harsh but i just dont understand this sort of weak minded bollocks

[emef]

i just listened to the tracks
you're taking the piss surely
asking for opinions at such an early stage of the track
they just sound like the same sound with the cutoff a bit more open on the second one

here's a tip...

automation
get some fucking movement in there

[Loz]

I love you, Michael.